Catalogue Raisonné of J. L.
Speranza’s Publications – H. P. Grice e J. L. Speranza: La Conversazione – I
Verbali: UZ
Speranza, J. L. (n. d.). ‘H. P.
Grice e J. L. Speranza: La Conversazione – I Verbali: Uziano – Ossia: Grice ed
Uziano – Grex griceiana – verbalia: Uziano. H. P. GRICE E J.
L. SPERANZA -- GREX -- VERBALIA: UTIANO The gens Utiana was an obscure plebeian
family of ancient Rome. None of its members are known from history, but two
appear in inscriptions that have attracted scholarly attention. Origin The nomen gentilicium Utianus is
probably an elaboration of the nomen Utius, and may be connected with an
epithet of the Oscan goddess Mefitis, referred to as "Mefitis Utiana"
in several inscriptions from Lucania.[1][2][3][4] Members This list includes abbreviated
praenomina. For an explanation of this practice, see filiation. Gaius Utianus
C. f. Rufus Latinianus, the son of Marcus Latinius, was adopted by a Gaius
Utianus, and became one of the municipal duumvirs of the Volceiani. He married
Insteia Polla, a priestess of the imperial cult, who first came to his house at
the age of seven, and was married to him for fifty-five years. Latinianus was
buried at Forum Popilii in Campania, along with his sister, Latinia Posilla, in
a tomb dating from the reign of Tiberius, and dedicated by his wife.[i] The
Decurions of the Volceiani honoured him with a public funeral and an equestrian
statue.[6][7] Marcus Utianus Onesimus, dedicated a tomb at Numistro in Lucania,
dating from the middle or later second century, for his wife, Ulpia Sperata.[8]
Notes The gravesite contains a depiction
of a head with three protruding legs surrounded by the letters "SIC".
Although the exact purpose of the artwork is unclear, the text may—according to
the classicist Roger Wilson—have functioned as an abbreviation for
"Sicilia".[5] References CIL
X, 131, CIL X, 132, CIL X, 133, AE 1974, 257.
Salomies 2013, p. 177. Kajava
2023, pp. 56, 57. Kajava 2025, pp. 151,
152. Wilson 2023, p. 7. Laes 2012, p. 108. AE 1910, 191. CIL X, 442. Bibliography René Cagnat et alii,
L'Année épigraphique (The Year in Epigraphy, abbreviated AE), Presses
Universitaires de France (1888–present). Kajava, Mika
(2023-01-10), Naming Gods. An Onomastic Study of Divine Epithets Derived from
Roman Anthroponyms, Suomen Tiedeseura, ISBN 978-951-653-491-9 Kajava, Mika
(2025-08-14). Bonne, Corinne (ed.). My Name is Your Name: Anthroponyms as
Divine Attributes in the Greco-Roman World. De Gruyter.
doi:10.1515/9783111647555/html. ISBN 978-3-11-164755-5. Laes, Christian (2012).
"Latin Inscriptions and the Life Course. Regio III (Bruttium and Lucania )
as a Test Case". Arctos. 46: 93–111. Theodor Mommsen et alii, Corpus
Inscriptionum Latinarum (The Body of Latin Inscriptions, abbreviated CIL),
Berlin-Brandenburgische Akademie der Wissenschaften (1853–present). Salomies,
Olli (2013). "The Nomina of the Samnites. A Checklist". Arctos: Acta
Philologica Fennica. 2012 (46): 177. ISSN 0570-734X. Archived from the original
on September 12, 2024. Wilson, Roger J. A. (2023). "A forgotten Roman
marble base in the National Museum of Archaeology". Malta Archaeological
Review. doi:10.46651/mar.2023.2. External links Wiktionary logo The dictionary
definition of Utianus at Wiktionary Category: Roman gentes And for THIS gens? Thanks
Speranza, J. L. (n. d.). ‘H. P.
Grice e J. L. Speranza: La Conversazione – I Verbali: Uziano – Ossia: Grice ed
Uziano – Grex griceiana – verbalia: Uziano. The Utiani are a
tiny gens, but they contain something that would have delighted both Grice and
Speranza: a case where identity itself is a conversational and legal artifact.
The obvious hero is: Gaius Utianus Rufus
Latinianus. [GREXv3 | Word] Why? Because
he is simultaneously: born a Latinius,
adopted by an Utianus, becomes Utianus Rufus Latinianus, municipal duumvir,
husband of Insteia Polla, honoured with a public funeral and equestrian statue.
[GREXv3 | Word] This is almost Austin
before Austin and Grice before Grice. A Roman adoption is not merely a
biological event. It is a juridical and conversational transformation. One
day: Marcus Latinius filium habet. The next day:
Gaius Utianus filium habet. The
physical person is unchanged. The social reality changes. In a Grice-Speranza
reconstruction: Magistrate: In familiam
Utianam recipitur. (He is received into the Utian family.) +> A new social identity comes into existence.
This is precisely the sort of thing later philosophers would call an
institutional fact. There is also the
remarkable inscription concerning his wife, Insteia Polla. The inscription
reports that she came into his household at the age of seven and remained
married to him for fifty-five years. After his death she dedicated the monument.
[GREXv3 | Word] Now that is not merely epigraphy. It is delayed conversation.
The tomb says: Remember him. But it also says: Remember us.
A Roman epitaph frequently has two speakers: the dead person commemorated, the living
dedicator. In this case the second voice
is especially strong. Even more
intriguing is the possible divine connection. Your dossier notes that: Utianus may be connected with Mefitis Utiana,
an epithet of the Oscan goddess Mefitis attested in Lucania. [GREXv3 |
Word] That is unusual. Most of the
gentes we have discussed derive from:
places, animals, occupations, personal traits. Here we may have a name touching the divine
sphere. Indeed, if the connection is right, the direction may be: person ↔ deity rather than simply: place ↔ person. That would have interested Varro enormously.
And perhaps Grice too, since it blurs the distinction between proper names and
descriptive epithets. You will also
enjoy the small mystery of the tomb decoration mentioned in your source: a head with three protruding legs accompanied
by the letters "SIC." The interpretation remains uncertain; one
suggestion is an abbreviation connected with "Sicilia." [GREXv3 |
Word] That immediately evokes a semiotic
puzzle. A sign survives. Its interpretive community disappears. We
possess: signum. But not reliably: signatum.
Exactly the sort of thing that would frustrate both the grammarian
Umbrius Primus and the haruspex Umbricius Melior. If I were to cast Gaius Utianus Rufus
Latinianus into a Grice seminar, it would run: Grice: "What changed when he was
adopted?" Austin: "A performative occurred." Roman jurist:
Nomen mutatum est. (The name was changed.) Grice:
"Not merely the name."
+> New rights. +> New
obligations. +> New relationships. +> New expectations. The utterance created a social world. And
that takes us back to your beloved Bologna. For the Roman jurists taught there
spent centuries analysing precisely such transformations: man and wife, adopter and adopted, testator
and heir, buyer and seller. The question
was always: What happened because
certain words, acts, and intentions were recognised? Which is not terribly far from Grice's own
question: What happens because one
person means something and another recognises that meaning? Among the obscure gentes, the Utiani
therefore give us not a grammarian, not a jurist, not a philosopher, but
something perhaps even more Roman: a man whose very identity depended on legal
recognition and whose name preserves the memory of that recognition. (Ha.) And
do you have one or more examples of words which in latin have the '-utia-'
cluster and become in modern Italian '-uzia-? Thanks Yes, although one must be
a little careful. The change from Latin -ti- to Italian -zi- is very common,
but it is not automatic in every word. One of the characteristic developments
of Italian is: Latin -ti- before a vowel
→ Italian -zi- (pronounced /ts/ or /dz/ depending on context). Classic examples are:
LatinItalianpatientiapazienzaprudentiaprudenzascientiascienzagratiagraziaplateapiazza
(through a more complex development)pretiumprezzo The family resemblance is
easy to hear: patientia → pazienza
prudentia → prudenza scientia → scienza
The cluster: -tia- becomes something like: -zia-
or -za-. Now your question concerns specifically: -utia- → ? -uzia- There are a few examples. Most famous is
perhaps: Latin astutia → Italian
astuzia ("cunning",
"craftiness"). This is almost textbook: astutia → astuzia. Another good example is: Latin minutia → Italian minuzia ("minuteness", "small
detail"). And because you have previously discussed Grice's minutae
majestatis and crimen minutionis, this one may especially appeal. So we
have:
LatinItalianastutiaastuziaminutiaminuzia These are genuine cases
where: -utia- becomes -uzia-. Now this brings us intriguingly close to your
Utianus. One must not infer an etymology from mere sound resemblance. Still, an
Italian ear accustomed to: astuzia,
minuzia, naturally hears -uzia- where a
Latinist sees historical -utia-. A Gricean observation might be that the hearer
reconstructs the historical form:
astuzia +> derives from
astutia. The modern Italian surface disguises the older Latin morphology.
Indeed, your succession of names: Utius
Utianus Utiana has a distinctly Italian
flavour because the Latin -ti- cluster is precisely one of those places where
Italian likes to produce -zi-. One could almost imagine a medieval Bolognese
jurist saying: astutia while his descendant says: astuzia.
The jurist is still reading Roman law; the language around him has
quietly changed. And since we were discussing Grice's perspicuity, there is a
nice parallel. Just as: speculatio →
speculative thought, preserves the old
Latin root spec-, so: astuzia quietly
preserves the older astutia underneath.
The history is no longer immediately visible, but it remains there for
the philologist to "see through" (perspicere), which is perhaps
exactly what a perspicacious reader does. (Ha.)


No comments:
Post a Comment